Haskell v. Katahdin Paper and GNP Maine Holdings

Insurance Company

Sedgwick CMS and MEMIC

Date Decided

December 13, 2017

Panel Members

Elizabeth Elwin

Sue Jerome

Evelyn Knopf




Multiple Injuries Ongoing Injury Gradual Injury Kidder Multiple Insurers

File Size

182 KB


Summary from the Troubh Heisler Attorneys

Mr. Haskell injured his neck in 2010 at Katahdin and again in 2013 at GNP. GNP apportioned against Katahdin based in part on a ยง312 IME report issued in 2011, 2 years before the 2013 DOI, finding that the 2010 injury was a significant aggravation of Mr. Haskell's pre-existing degenerative cervical disc disease.

In the apportionment case, Judge Hirtle considered "the only medical opinion on the issue of apportionment" that attributed 15% to the 2013 injury and 85% to Mr. Haskell's pre-existing condition. Under the Maine Supreme Court's 1975 Kidder decision, Judge Hirtle was permitted to apportion liability 50/50 if "apportionment is impossible" otherwise. Judge Hirtle rejected the only apportionment opinion before him, because it suggested that Mr. Haskell's prior condition was degenerative cervical disc disease. In addition, the mill medical records "documented the ongoing nature of Mr. Haskell's 2010 injury."

Page |