Name
Al-Zubaidi v. Barber Foods LLC
Insurance Company
Self-Insured
Date Decided
July 9, 2026
Panel Members
David Hirtle
Donald Murphy
Lindsey Sands
Categories
Board IMETags
File Size
180 KB
DownloadSummary from the Troubh Heisler Attorneys
Al-Zubaidi v. Barber Foods LLC- Appellate Division affirms ALJ adoption of Dr. Donovan’s 312 IME conclusions. The presence of conflicting evidence does not compel a contrary result where the IME conclusions were supported by competent evidence. The Appellate Division will reverse an ALJ’s adoption of 312 IME conclusions only if the findings are not supported by competent evidence or the record discloses no reasonable basis to adopt those findings.